Trauma Stories in Parental Alienation

We are back in London after our work in Zagreb, which has led to discussions about the next European Association of Parental Alienation Practitioners conference in 2020, at which we will launch the standards of practice and training in this field for use across all European borders.

These standards will be the first worldwide protocols of intervention with families affected by parental alienation and will be developed in conjunction with mental health and legal professionals who are leading in this field in Europe.

It is time now to define and declare the route forward for this work and to stand by our knowledge and skill base in making this replicable. With the joining together of powerful practitioners in Europe, such as  Prof. Dr. Sc. Gordana Bujlan Flander in Croatia and Dr Simona Vlădică in Romania, this project is in rapid development.

Whilst in Zagreb I saw more of the widespread harm the problem of a child’s pathological alignment and rejection of a parent causes. This is a problem without borders, it is a child abuse scandal hiding in plain sight.  Our lecture room was full and there was another room full of parents watching via live stream. In the days since we delivered the lecture, it has been watched around the world thousands of times and we have received many messages in response.

I know how damaging this issue is.  To the child, to the parent they are rejecting and yes, also, to the parent to whom the child is pathologically aligned.

I know how damaging it is to professionals who work with these families, the risk of complaint and sanction is high as this is a highly litigious and psychologically unwell group of people and ultimately, this is damaging to the fabric of our society, as a significant group of families fail to get the help that they need.

We are living with a phenomenon which has shown its face in the post separation landscape and which causes trauma to all concerned and yet for five decades we have ignored that trauma in favour of pretending that if everyone simply gets on with divorce and separation, children will get over it.

And whilst many children do, (after a fashion) get over it, some children don’t.  And those who don’t are those who are living a trauma story which reveals itself in the dynamics we as practitioners can readily observe.

In the therapy room with alienating parents, the story of what has happened to them becomes very obvious. Driven to behave in ways that cause children to defend against the impossibility of holding two realities in mind, these parents cannot and/or will not see the damage they are doing to their children.  For some this is a deliberate campaign of denigration of the other parent, for others it is a firm and yet delusional belief that they are protecting the child from harm.

Parental alienation is not just the story of what happened to the rejected parent although that is where our gaze is drawn to as rejected parents tell us their story. Parental alienation is the story of what happened to the parent to whom the child is pathologically aligned and the story of what that does to the child over time.

The traumatic impact on the rejected parent however, is life changing and life limiting, it is unrecognised and it is often emphasised by the appalling lack of compassion shown by unaware professionals.  One of the worst scenes I have ever witnessed, was the unconscious and yet deeply damaging harm done to a rejected parent who had just seen her children for the first time in four years, when a social worker asked her if she would like her to give the gifts she had brought and her children had refused, to charity.

The story of what has happened to the child is obvious when we understand the story of what happened to the alienating parent, the resulting behavioural patterns in post separation parenting and how the rejected parent responded to that.

Those triangulated dynamics – the actions of one, the responses of the other and the resilience or lack of it in the child, are the story of how alienation takes hold.  It is the actions of one parent which begin the story, the responses both positive and negative from the other parent which act as the vehicle upon which the dysfunction is carried (by which I mean that alienation requires a rejected parent and the rejected parent is required to be the vehicle for the dynamics which are triggered) and the child’s capacity to resist or not is ingredient the story to be completed.  It is when the three ingredients are right (alienating strategies plus rejected parent responses plus a child without resilience to the alienation)  that a child uses psychological splitting as a defence. The emergence of an omnipotent self as a defence against the impossible, is what gives rise to the signs of alienation in the child.

That is not to say that rejected parents cause parental alienation, far from it. Neither is it to say that rejected parents are even the primary focus of the trauma story in parental alienation because whilst they suffer trauma, that trauma is a by product of what has happened to the child.

The real trauma story is in the parent to whom the child has become pathologically bound and in the alienated child where the story of trauma is told through the experiences of adults who were alienated as children and who were not helped to resolve the traumatic splitting they suffered.  This group of children who are now adults, tells the story of the trauma story in the here and now via their struggle as adults to resolve the split state of mind which began in childhood.   It is this project which I am most concerned with in my research and this project which gives clues to the life long damage that is done by parental alienation.

Transmission of trauma through the family affected by parental alienation is the unfolding story in this drama and it is time these stories were told.  In Zagreb, as in Warsaw last month, in Belgium earlier this year and in Romania early this month, the same trauma stories are told.  From around the globe trauma is suffered in families affected by parental alienation and it is time now to make these stories visible in the world.

Abused children of divorce and separation in this generation and the next, depend upon us to make their silenced voices heard.


Readers may wish to listen to the excellent programme about parental alienation which includes some of the trauma stories we hear in the therapy room which was made by Psychotherapist Philippa Perry for BBC Radio 4 here.


 

 

 

9 Comments

  1. This blog post should be on all mandatory reading lists for trainee social workers, psychologists, health professionals esp CAMHS & paediatricians, and lawyers/barristers/judiciary.
    Brilliant written & captures our case perfectly. I want to print the whole thing & add it to the position statement for next court hearing!

    Liked by 1 person

  2. You are brilliant.

    And on the eve of my gorgeous child’s birthday who has been alienated from me I thank you for this great work.

    Wishing counseling for everyone based on these principles and let the healing and love begin❤️😇🙏🇨🇦🍀💙

    Like

    1. Colleen,

      I hope you have made plans for yourself to get through your daughter’s birthday.

      Keep strong 💐🌻🌼🌹🌺⚘

      Like

  3. I recognize ALL describitions. Which i am live in.
    I am also a pedagogue. In my work i lift up, stretch and give to pupils, thats the bit of the pedagogic work.

    I ask for more enlightening.
    1. Whom goes to the alienting patent with two witnesses and telling them the wrong they are doing to the Child? The alientor beliefs they are doing right.

    2. Whom telling the rest of the family whats going on? There are often a bad groupculture involved. With new partners, gradparents who is lied to about the targed parent and so on.
    It is important to split this bad groupculture. They having a dark fence around the child. And keeping up the liars..

    3. It is of highest importance that we also use the connection to mocking and bulluying. This is somehing People understand. There are programs against bulluying. People know it is about frezing out, false accusements ans so on.

    Parental alienation is a foggy area. To understand that it is not about a bad relation between the target parent and the Child, or teenageproblems, many beliefs that, maybe it is easier to understand to the link to bulluying and mocking.

    3. I really hope this serious social problem can be solved outside courtroom.
    It s a too long way to go there because In courtroom the rethoric, liars and lack of ethics rules. Even if they are enlightened about parental alienation.

    In courtroom there a traditional thinking to one winner and one looser. The system thinking is old. Its a huge ship, hard to turn. Do not be naive.

    And it is too expencive. It is not fair that only highincome people shall save the relationship to the children.

    Let target people have help in public Offices, for the childrens best. And link to Childs convention of rights.
    And ask UN to renew it.

    Like

  4. Great article and as you suggest it is important to realise there is a whole spectrum of cases here from the deliberate targeting of one parent by another at one extreme to situations where the alienating parent merely reacts to their own hurt thinking, incorrectly, that they are similarly protecting the child.

    It is also non gender specific as either parent (mother or father) can be the alienating one or the target.

    Like

  5. Great post, Karen

    Celebrated my 57th birthday a couple of days ago (13-Jul)…the same day that my eldest daughter reached the age of 28. A daughter who, despite my repeated efforts to remain in her life, has refused to share our birthday celebrations in any way whatsoever post-separation/divorce in early 2001

    Yes, Parental Alienation really is a scandal ‘hiding in plain sight’, whether because of (a)the sheer incompetence of so many professionals entrusted with assessing PA cases and the well-being of the child, (b)the failure of the court system to identify and challenge alienating parent behaviour, (c)the lack of support afforded to rejected parents who are emotionally and psychologically traumatised by the actions of the aligned parent (as you say, often, first being forced into ‘split thinking’ as a child and then being re-traumatised, as an adult, when the same experience is endured by their own child) or a combination of all three

    Today, I see my own 80-year old alienating parent who is still in denial and/or delusion about the impact (on me) of those alienation tactics 50 years ago. I see an ex-spouse who, equally, refuses to take any responsibility for (or sees anything wrong with) the split mind of our daughter over the past 18+ years. I also see a 28-year old, emotionally immature, young lady who is destined (along with her siblings) to ‘continue the cycle’……..unless and until she chooses to step out of the darkness that is PA and has become entrenched within in our family over generations

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s